Publication Policy and Prior Art
Policy on Previous PublicationPreviously published papers may not be submitted, nor may work be submitted to any other conference or journal, during the SIGGRAPH 2007 papers review period. For more details, e.g. on submission of abstracts to other conferences, see the Double Submissions section of Frequently Asked Questions. A paper is considered previously published if it has appeared in a peer-reviewed journal or meeting proceedings that are visibly, reliably, and permanently available afterward in print or electronically to non-attendees, regardless of the language of that publication.
Publications such as theses, tech reports, patents, or abstracts in other conferences do not preclude subsequent publication of a complete paper on the same topic by the same authors. However, such publications by other authors are considered prior art and should be cited as such. Whether this or any other form of prior art "scoops" (precludes publication of) your paper or not is up to the reviewers. Talks and presentations (including SIGGRAPH Sketches and Posters) can be cited, but they need not be, and they are not considered prior art.
(Note: SIGGRAPH Sketches have appeared in the ACM Digital Library in some years but not others. Beginning in 2007, they will not appear there. Thus, they are not reliably available outside the SIGGRAPH community, and therefore they should not be considered as prior art. Again, individual reviewers may have their own point of view.)
Public Disclosure of Conditional and Final AcceptancesPublic disclosure of a paper's title, abstract, and contents can have important commercial and legal ramifications. Acceptances are finalized around the beginning of May, at which time the paper's title, abstract, and 30-word summary (written by the authors) may be disclosed publicly in SIGGRAPH 2007 communications. Excerpts of the paper's companion video may also be disclosed. The full paper will not appear until the official publication date of the conference, which is 29 July 2007.
No information about rejected papers or papers conditionally accepted for publication in ACM Transactions on Graphics will be made public.